earthweal guest weekly challenge: LOOKING FOR A NEW HIERARCHY

by Sarah Connor

I first came across Maslow’s hierarchy at college. I didn’t think too much about it – I had a lot of facts to learn, and this was just another one. Two or three times in my life I’ve learned the triangle well enough to be able to answer a multiple-choice question on it, if it should happen to come up. It has face validity. What more do you want?

You know Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, right? It’s been around since 1943. It’s been meme-ed.

 

 

Maslow stated that you move up through the hierarchy. You need to have your physiological needs met first, then safety, then love and belonging, esteem, self-actualization. The big joke these days is that you need to add a further foundation layer, usually labelled “wi-fi”.

Obviously.

It wasn’t until I came across a random tweet the other day that I even questioned this. The tweeter pointed out that Maslow was writing from a particular time and place (America in the 1940s), and his thinking was inevitably affected by the culture he was living in. She gave “ubuntu” as an alternative to self-actualization as the highest point on the pyramid.

I spent a happy half hour or so following up the comments, which led me to read a little more about ubuntu, and to the work of Max-Neef, who flattens out that hierarchy.

In fairness to Maslow, maybe he created a visual image that was just too powerful. We know (and he acknowledged) that this is not a rigid pyramid. You can be hungry and still take joy in great art, you can be homeless and still enjoy friendship, you can use creativity to manage your insecurities.

Ubuntu is a word from Southern Africa that can be translated as “humanity”. The philosophy of ubuntu was first developed by Jordan Kush Ngubane in the 1950s – again, an idea developed in a particular time and place, this time a continent developing a post-colonial identity. The basic idea of ubuntu is that I am human because you are human. We create each other’s humanity. This is a much more community, relationship-based view of what makes a complete human than the “self-actualization” we value so much in western society. Archbishop Desmond Tutu was an exponent of ubuntu, and it influenced his work on reconciliation in post-apartheid South Africa. Here’s a description of ubuntu from him:

A person with Ubuntu is open and available to others, affirming of others, does not feel threatened that others are able and good, based from a proper self-assurance that comes from knowing that he or she belongs in a greater whole and is diminished when others are humiliated or diminished, when others are tortured or oppressed.

Why did I follow up this particular tweet? Why am I writing about these ideas? I brought them to earthweal because they struck a chord with me – because I’ve just been watching these ideas brought to life during the covid lockdown and as we emerge from that. At the moment, viewing all those videos of people throwing tantrums because they are being asked to wear masks in communal spaces and seeing reports of people rushing to beaches and other public spaces, crowding together and leaving literally tons of rubbish behind them,  makes me wonder if we’ve taken the whole “self-actualization” thing a bit too far.  Poor old Maslow. I don’t think he intended us to think that self-actualization meant prioritising our individual wishes over everything and everybody else, but here we are.

On the other hand, during lockdown it was our communities that we missed. The communities we form at work, with extended family, with friends, all of those were stripped away from us. What did we do? We formed virtual choirs. We did Zoom quizzes. We attended Teams meetings. We connected with people in new ways, different ways, ways that weren’t quite the same, weren’t quite as satisfying, but did go some way towards fulfilling that need to connect with others, to be acknowledged as human and to acknowledge others.

This is not a surprise. We know it takes a village to raise a child. We know that we are primates, we live in troops.  We’ve agreed that more than 15 days of solitary confinement is a cruel and inhumane punishment (and look at that word “inhumane” – that says it all). Social media is all about connecting. It uses the languages of relationships – liking, friends – and yet it leaves us wanting more. It’s not satisfying, it’s addictive. We crave the likes, when what we really crave is real connection. It’s not in Facebook’s interest to satisfy us. It wants us there, scrolling for connection. While we’re scrolling we’re seeing adverts, we’re having our data harvested. Twitter doesn’t want us to feel content. It wants us to come back for more. I’m not saying you can’t create community through social media, but I am saying there’s big money to be made out of our drive to connect with others.

At the same time, we all need moments of privacy. We’ve all kept secret diaries, we’ve all wanted to be alone. As poets and creators we need space to write and to create – and yet that writing and creating is ultimately a communication with others. As we try to effect change we have to take individual responsibility and individual action, but without a community of activists around us we are doomed to failure. There’s a balance here – movements are inspired by individuals, but it’s that movement that supports those individuals to make a difference. Greta Thunberg was admirable when she stood alone with her Skolstrejk för klimatet sign. She’s important because she inspired a movement around the world. Jane Goodall’s chimpanzee studies are fascinating, but she’s important because she communicated them and used them as a basis to advocate for environmental and community development.

Let’s try a little mind experiment. Go back to Maslow’s triangle. What would happen if we erased “self-actualization” and put “ubuntu” in its place? If we stated that fulfilling ourselves through our connections with others was the highest place on the pyramid? Now let’s take it a step further. What would happen if, instead of ubuntu, we chose a different word – a word that doesn’t exist yet – a word that means connecting with the whole web of life across this planet? What would it mean to state that the highest level of personal development came through connection with the whole eco-system?

This week, I’d like you to think about that balance between the individual and the community. Where do you stand on the spectrum between lone wolf and team-player? How does your community support you? What are the communities you’ve chosen? What are the communities that have been thrust upon you? Can we be human without other humans?  What are the threads that stitch us into place? They may be good or bad, or somewhere in between, but they are certainly there.

— Sarah

13 thoughts on “earthweal guest weekly challenge: LOOKING FOR A NEW HIERARCHY

    • Thank YOU Sarah for stepping up to the plate! i know this will be a fruitful challenge and yes, thoughtful replies take time. My most trenchant one so far I posted to the open link weekend, but I’m working on it … A poem about Rupert Murdoch posted today works in reverse, but I’ll try to stay more on topic for my contribution. The same principle of ubuntu in the human community underlies our place in the greater living and nonliving communities on this planet … Brendan

      Like

  1. Your prompt reminded me of a dream last week, and although it was not community-based, it was family-centred. What better community is there than family? Thank you for the prompt.

    Like

  2. Sarah, I LOVE that you have written about ubuntu. “I am well if you are well.” An inclusive way forward, away from all the divisiveness. I love Desmond Tutu’s quote. Oh and you really made my mind take a leap when you suggested we connect WITH THE ENTIRE ECOSYSTEM. YES!!!!!! That is the leap humanity needs right now as, underneath the virus, the climate crisis continues to accelerate. What a fantastic essay and challenge this is. Inspiring.

    Like

  3. Sarah, I enjoyed reading your essay. This is an appropriate time for self-examination and collective self-examination. We need to plan for how we can become better than we are as we reconstruct our lives, our communities, our economies, and our environment in the wake of the Pandemic.

    Best Regards,

    Cheryl Batavia

    Like

  4. wow what a great prompt. so much of what i felt and thought did not end up in my poem. but i suppose sometimes those are the best. that we are in fact one, that anything i do for me i do for all of humanity. how my years as a lone wolf were spend on *avoiding* introspection! lol! this world is so fascinating!

    Like

  5. That’s an excellent essay. Intuitively it makes much more sense to have ubuntu at the top of the hierarchy of needs. The idea of making it the ecosystem is very provocative. You’ve certainly set out to get a reaction from us!

    Like

  6. Thanks you for the interesting prompt Sarah – been chewing it over all week. Looking forward to reading all the responses. (In my understanding, uBuntu predates colonisation though – Jordan Kush Ngubane wrote about but did not create it.)

    Like

  7. I think you’re right about uBuntu – it was certainly there, but I got the impression that Jordan Kush Ngubane developed it as a social map for a post-colonial world. I am skimming the surface here, though – it was a new word to me (though Clinton used the word, too), and it seemed to stand in striking contrast to the idea of self-individuation. Your poem says “a solitary human is a contradiction in terms”, and that just sums things up, really. Thank you for chewing it over, and coming back with something so thoughtful and meaningful.

    Liked by 1 person

    • i do have to own that the solitary human quote you mention is a rewording of something Archbishop Desmond Tutu said when talking about uBuntu – but so far down the rabbit hole i cannot find it to double check i am not accidentally quoting him. And yes we dutifully learned Maslow’s hierarchy of needs in high school – definitely time to rethink our purpose and what really is at the top of that pyramid(or if there is a pyramid at all.

      Like

      • eek….a quick google search shows it to be a direct quote from him – dang – i will have to fix that super quick.

        Like

Leave a Reply to pennygadd51 Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.